+1 (365) 317-0199 he***@***************es.com

Something’s going on with how Canadians are picking mortgages this year, and I don’t think the headlines are getting it quite right.

This summer, only 8.8% of Canadians signed a fixed mortgage for five years or longer.

Nearly half used to. Variable-rate mortgages now make up more than 40% of new agreements, up from under 10% in 2024.

I work with borrowers whose files don’t fit the standard boxes, so a lot of my day goes to thinking about what a mortgage does when things change.

And this move to shorter terms looks to me like mostly a structure decision, which is a different conversation than the one happening in the news, where it’s all about the rate.

Structure is what I’d look at first in your file, honestly before rate.

What’s Actually Driving the Shift

I get the appeal. The lowest five-year variable sits near 3.43% and fixed is around 4.34%, so you put two payments side by side and one’s smaller. Pretty easy math.

But the rate is just one number on the page. How the whole thing is set up, the term, the renewal date, what happens when rates move, that’s where the risk actually sits.

Economists at National Bank have warned that when this many homeowners hold short-term or variable products, the whole housing market gets jumpier about rate hikes, bond yield moves, and shocks like oil prices swinging.

Policy changes hit household budgets faster. Harder too.

That’s the big-picture view. I care more about what it looks like at somebody’s kitchen table, usually next to a renewal letter that sat unopened for a week.

💡 A mortgage term protects you when it fits your real situation and you know how it acts under stress. A five-year term can still go wrong for you, and so can a one-year.

The Renewal Wave Sitting Behind All This

This next part is the one I keep coming back to.

Roughly 1.15 million mortgages are renewing this year, and fixed-rate holders are expected to see payments go up around 20% on average.

About 60% of all Canadian mortgages come up for renewal by the end of 2026, and a lot of those will land at higher rates than the ones they’re leaving.

Many of these borrowers signed below 2% during the pandemic. Their options now start above 4%.

You could see that coming years ago, and still I keep meeting people who feel blindsided by it. I honestly don’t know why. Maybe the letters show up too late, maybe it’s just easier not to look.

That ties right back to the short-term trend. Picking a one- or two-year term today puts you back in that renewal line sooner, on purpose, and it’s a bet that rates at your next renewal will be friendlier than today’s.

Sometimes that’s a good bet. For a borrower expecting an income change, a sale, or a refinance inside a set window, it can be exactly the right setup, as long as it’s a deliberate sequence and the next step is already planned.

Actually, the next two steps, if I’m being picky.

Where it goes sideways is when the term got picked on rate and nothing else.

The Policy Backdrop Is Less Comfortable Than It Looks

The Bank of Canada has held its overnight rate at 2.25% for seven straight decisions, unchanged since October 2025. A long hold feels like stability, and I think that feeling is behind a lot of borrowing choices right now.

The Bank’s published neutral range runs from 2.25% to 3.25%, though. So we’re sitting at the very bottom of it.

RBC Economics expects the policy rate to hit 3.25% by the end of 2027. National Bank says 2.75%.

To me a hold at the bottom of neutral looks like a pause, and it could move either way.

Locking in a big yearly payment on the idea that this calm sticks around is a real risk. Rates could drop too, I just wouldn’t build a budget on it.

⚠️ Projections show the lowest five-year variable rate going from about 3.35% today to roughly 4.60% by 2028. If your budget only works at today’s rate, it’s worth running it again at that higher number.

One more thing, and it’s a bit wonky. The spread between the five-year government bond yield and the best fixed rates has shrunk to about 71 basis points, way below the usual 100 to 200.

Lenders are eating some margin right now. If that flips, fixed rates could climb faster than bond yields, and anyone waiting for a better moment may find it already passed.

Who This Actually Hurts, Including People With Decent Credit

I want to be straight with you about this part.

Equifax Canada’s latest data shows severe mortgage delinquency up 33.8% year over year by balance.

What stopped me was who’s in that number: financially stable homeowners with decent credit scores, people in the 621 to 680 range who’ve usually been seen as lower risk. I read that range twice, thinking I’d got it wrong.

These borrowers didn’t suddenly get careless. Their structure stopped fitting their life when rates moved, and it sounds like a lot of them never had someone show them what that would feel like in a monthly budget.

This gets missed a lot in the fixed-versus-variable debate.

I’d ask a different question before the product one: given your income, your timeline, what’s coming up in your life, and how much payment movement you can stand, what setup holds up when the stuff you can’t control goes wrong?

When I sit down with a client, I get the full picture before I recommend anything. Self-employed income that bounces around. A business sale eighteen months out. A credit file still healing.

Each of those changes which structure makes sense, and skipping them to chase the lowest advertised rate is how people end up paying more later with less room to move.

How to Stress-Test Your Own Decision

You can pressure-test your own mortgage without being a broker. It takes about an hour and some honesty with your numbers.

  • Price your payment at renewal rates. If you’re signing a short term now, run your payment at 4.60% and see if your household can carry it without strain. Then try 5%, just to see. This is the one I’d start with, because it takes ten minutes and it’s usually the number that changes how people feel about the whole decision.
  • Know your trigger point if you’re going variable. Count how many rate increases sit between your payment now and a restructuring talk.
  • Map out the next three years. If you plan to sell, refinance, or restructure, the term should end around when that plan does.
  • Ask your advisor to walk through the downside out loud. If the answer stays vague, that tells you something.

I tell the people sitting across from me that there’s almost always a workable path, and it starts with knowing exactly what you’re signing and why.

I treat every recommendation like it’s for family, so I’ll give you the hard news now rather than let your renewal do it.

Where I Land on It

Shorter terms can be fine. For the right borrower with a real plan, it’s a smart sequence.

For someone who picked it because the payment looked smaller, it’s a lot of risk they probably haven’t looked at yet.

What separates those two borrowers is mostly whether anyone looked at the whole situation before signing.

Sometimes that’s a broker, sometimes it’s just the borrower with a spreadsheet and a free Saturday.

A full point higher on renewal day is the scenario I’d run first. That’s where I’d start, anyway.

The Mortgage Minute with Carmen Costa

Once a month, I’ll send you things I wish every homeowner knew: what’s happening with rates, what to check before you renew your mortgage, and practical ways to make your money work harder.

Plain language, no sales pitch.

Skip to content